60 shops in New Jersey (NJ) carry Magic: The Gathering.
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated5.0(475 reviews)
85 Godwin Avenue, Midland Park, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
The Toy & Comic Spot
Top Rated5.0(167 reviews)
1889 New Jersey 88, Brick Township, NJ
Discover The Toy & Comic Spot – the ultimate comic book store Jersey Shore for back issues, graded comics, vintage toys,…
Victory Point
Top Rated5.0(76 reviews)
112 Brunswick Street, Jersey City, NJ
Fantastic Local Game Store for Every Gamer! This place is awesome! They have MTG Commander nights every Tuesday and Sat…
The Player Agency
Top Rated5.0(68 reviews)
5 Mead Street, South Orange Village, NJ
Nestled in the heart of South Orange Village, this vibrant hub brings together fans of Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu…
The Gathering House LLC
5.0(42 reviews)
1911 New Jersey 27, Edison, NJ
Providing LIVE stream and shoppable TCG products in store, online, and on our social media LIVES. We provide entertainme…
Progress CCG
5.0(40 reviews)
2019 Greenwood Lake Turnpike, West Milford, NJ
Progress CCG is a Collectibles and Trading card online store with a physical presence. From Pokémon to Star Wars and eve…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.9(464 reviews)
1825 New Jersey 35, Wall Township, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.9(417 reviews)
1500 Almonesson Road, Deptford, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.9(325 reviews)
1170 Town Center Way, Livingston, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.9(273 reviews)
739 New Jersey 18, East Brunswick, NJ
Monmouth Trading Cards is an outstanding shop! From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted by Johnathan, whose…
Gilded Raven Games
Top Rated4.9(180 reviews)
120 Cedar Grove Lane, Franklin Township, NJ
Wandered in here today after stumbling across nearby gaming stores in the area. After reading the reviews, I figured it…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.9(179 reviews)
2274 Wrangleboro Road, Hamilton, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
the geekery
Top Rated4.9(145 reviews)
19 Little Street, Matawan, NJ
Nestled in Matawan, New Jersey, this beloved local haven has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from 145 reviews. The Geek…
Paul's Toy Room - Toys, Collectables, Gaming, Warhammer, & Hobby Supplies
Top Rated4.9(82 reviews)
3322 Washington Road, Sayreville, NJ
Tucked away in Sayreville, New Jersey, this beloved local spot offers an impressive mix of trading cards, collectables,…
Peninsula Games
Top Rated4.9(80 reviews)
604 2nd Avenue, Long Branch, NJ
Looking for a dedicated spot to grab singles, sealed product, or a quick game near the Jersey Shore? Tucked away in Long…
ichooseyou TCGs
Top Rated4.9(68 reviews)
5 Lenape Road, Andover, NJ
ichooseyou TCGs sells factory sealed Pokemon, Flesh and Blood, Lorcana, and Magic the Gathering products.
Hobby Vault
Top Rated4.9(66 reviews)
300 South Lenola Road, Maple Shade, NJ
Hobby, Game, and Toy store featuring some of the biggest and best brands. We have Magic the Gathering, Pokemon, Yu-Gi-…
Phenomenal Games
Top Rated4.9(55 reviews)
100 North White Horse Pike, Lindenwold, NJ
From the moment I walked into the game store, Pabel’s warm smile and confidence caught my attention. There was something…
Garden State TCG LLC
Top Rated4.9(50 reviews)
366 Wheat Road, Vineland, NJ
Your base for all your favorite TCGs & Collectibles at a fair price.
Scroll and Circuit Games
4.9(35 reviews)
2999 East Evesham Road, Voorhees Township, NJ
My wife and I just discovered your store today while searching for Pokémon cards. We were extremely surprised by the var…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.8(1096 reviews)
310 New Jersey 36, West Long Branch, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
Conquest Comics
Top Rated4.8(364 reviews)
657 U.S. 9, Berkeley Township, NJ
Tucked away in Berkeley Township, this local gem has earned a stellar 4.8-star rating from over 360 reviews, and it’s ea…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated4.8(278 reviews)
1041 New Jersey 73, Evesham, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
Highlander Games
Top Rated4.8(258 reviews)
123 Boonton Avenue, Boonton, NJ
Nice gaming store. They have tables set up for events such as magic the gathering commander, modern and legacy formats.…
The Bearded Dragon Games
Top Rated4.8(228 reviews)
123 Claremont Road, Bernardsville, NJ
Very nice local game store. They have great presentation and lots of different games to offer. I have been going there r…
Dewey's Comic City
Top Rated4.8(128 reviews)
6 Green Village Road, Madison, NJ
Dewey's Comic City opened its doors in 1991 aiming to create a haven for comic enthusiasts. What began as a modest shop…
IRL Game Shop
Top Rated4.8(66 reviews)
755 New Jersey 18, East Brunswick, NJ
This place is so awesome! It is one of the best concepts for an entertainment business I've seen in so long. The staff a…
Expired Robot
Top Rated4.8(55 reviews)
1477 New Jersey 23, Butler, NJ
Located on NJ-23 in Butler, New Jersey and carries Comic Books New & Old, Pokemon, Magic, Plus other TCG and Collectible…
Zapp! Comics
Top Rated4.7(576 reviews)
574 Valley Road, Wayne, NJ
Find the latest comics, toys, and Pokemon trading cards and action figures at our online store. Browse our extensive col…
Comic Relief of Toms River
Top Rated4.7(285 reviews)
1341 Lakewood Road, Toms River, NJ
Looking for a dedicated spot to trade, battle, and stock up on singles? In Toms River, New Jersey, you’ll find a compact…
NuevaLinea (Toy & Game House)
Top Rated4.7(248 reviews)
5203 Bergenline Avenue, West New York, NJ
Tucked into the vibrant community of West New York, NJ, this family-run game haven is a go-to spot for trading card enth…
The Baseball Card Store Inc
Top Rated4.7(166 reviews)
45 Prospect Street, Midland Park, NJ
Come visit the store! Celebrating our 36th year in the same location. Located in Midland Park, NJ, the Baseball Card Sto…
Unshredded Nostalgia
Top Rated4.7(69 reviews)
323 South Main Street, Barnegat Township, NJ
Tucked away in Barnegat Township, this hobby hotspot caters to collectors and duelists who crave a curated selection of…
The Guild Hall Hobby
4.7(33 reviews)
400 New Jersey 38, Moorestown, NJ
Multiple miniature game systems such as 40k & Kill Team, Age of Sigmar & Warcry, Marvel Crisis Protocol and Star Wars Le…
South Jersey Cards
4.7(15 reviews)
17 Washington Street, Mount Holly, NJ
Nestled in historic Mount Holly, this beloved local card shop has earned a stellar 4.7-star rating from its community. W…
Dave's Time Warp Comics & Games
4.6(543 reviews)
555A Pompton Avenue, Cedar Grove, NJ
Tucked away in Cedar Grove, this beloved local hub has earned a stellar 4.6-star rating from over 540 reviews by keeping…
A Little Shop of Comics
4.6(299 reviews)
509 Berckman Street, Plainfield, NJ
Tucked away in Plainfield, NJ, this beloved local spot has earned a stellar 4.6-star rating from 299 reviews for good re…
Greg's Games
4.6(277 reviews)
2103 Whitehorse Mercerville Road, Hamilton Township, NJ
Prices for booster boxes and some events are absolute cheeks. Why charge so much more when most other stores are chargi…
Army & Navy
4.6(242 reviews)
39 New Jersey 36, Keyport, NJ
Tucked away in the heart of Keyport, New Jersey, this veteran-run shop is a true local hotspot for trading card enthusia…
The Card Capital
4.6(130 reviews)
900 Haddon Avenue, Collingswood, NJ
Shop baseball cards online or visit our Collingswood NJ store. Raw, graded, wax boxes and more. Trade, grade and collect…
World of Wax Sports Cards Randolph
4.6(98 reviews)
81 New Jersey 10, Randolph, NJ
WOW Sports Cards USA carries everything from trading cards to autographs and more!
Warhammer
4.6(89 reviews)
1121 New Jersey 34, Aberdeen Township, NJ
Collect, build, and paint miniatures, and fight strategic tabletop battles. The best hobby in the world is waiting for y…
Mom and Pop Shop Collectibles LLC
4.6(34 reviews)
185 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ
Supporting a family-owned business run by a fellow Bayonne native is always a pleasure! This place truly has something s…
Pop Stop and Pokemon Shop
4.5(29 reviews)
108 South Main Street, Neptune Township, NJ
A Pokemon Certified Store offering Pokemon TCG Training and Pokemon Leagues. We offer a massive variety of Funko Pops a…
New World Manga
4.4(323 reviews)
93 East Mount Pleasant Avenue, Livingston, NJ
Very nice comic book and trading card game store with friendly players and kind employees. The Magic the Gathering commu…
Saga Concepts
4.4(189 reviews)
35 South Van Brunt Street, Englewood, NJ
Being fourteen year old kids spending $200 on a model kit was a tough ask to our parents. There was a great deal of effo…
Amazing Heroes
4.0(176 reviews)
1025A Stuyvesant Avenue, Union, NJ
These are the books and items that Amazing Heroes is getting in this week. The Previews Order form has HUNDREDS of other…
Play! Hoboken
4.0(113 reviews)
1012 Grand Street, Hoboken, NJ
For trading card enthusiasts in Hoboken, this welcoming shop is a must-visit destination. Open seven days a week, it car…
FOCO
2.1(83 reviews)
444 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ
Find your fandom with FOCO.com! Welcome to your #1 source for officially licensed MLB, NFL, NBA, NHL, MLS, Premier Leagu…
Sigma Games
14 Mountain Avenue, Bound Brook, NJ
Sigma Games is a trading card shop in Bound Brook, NJ, located at 14 Mountain Avenue. The store carries Pokemon, Magic:…
Cardboard Colosseum
5.0(34 reviews)
118 South Broadway, South Amboy, NJ
Cardboard Colosseum is a trading card shop in South Amboy, NJ, located at 118 South Broadway. The store carries Pokemon,…
House Of Cards
5.0(9 reviews)
288 U.S. 22, Green Brook Township, NJ
House Of Cards is a trading card shop in Green Brook Township, NJ, located at 288 U.S. 22. The store carries Pokemon, Ma…
Sidekick Supplies
5.0(8 reviews)
123 Green Street, Woodbridge Township, NJ
At SideKick we are comic collectors first, with a side quest to protect your comic books from damage in a half-full stor…
The Card Brokers
5.0(1 reviews)
4 Robin Road, Rumson, NJ
The Card Brokers is a trading card shop in Rumson, NJ, located at 4 Robin Road. The store carries Pokemon, Magic: The Ga…
Card Shop Near Me
Top Rated4.9(72 reviews)
2025 Old Trenton Road, West Windsor Township, NJ
Card Shop Near Me is a trading card shop in West Windsor Township, NJ, located at 2025 Old Trenton Road. The store carri…
The Card Nest
Top Rated4.8(128 reviews)
486 Boulevard, Kenilworth, NJ
Shop The Card Nest to find great deals on all kinds of trading card games, board games, table top games, and more! Shop…
Koros Wargames
Top Rated4.8(70 reviews)
257 U.S. 202, Flemington, NJ
Koros Wargames is a gem of a store. I can’t believe it’s taken me this long to write a review! They are my go to stop f…
Cryptid Toys & Games
4.8(37 reviews)
6 North Forklanding Road, Maple Shade, NJ
Our Quantum Echoes algorithm marks a big step toward the first real-world applications of quantum computing.
East Coast Gamers
Top Rated4.7(247 reviews)
43 Main Street, Toms River, NJ
The staff is very welcoming and has a wide range of games from different consoles and media. They even reached out to me…
RNG-Gamez
Top Rated4.7(185 reviews)
2325 Plainfield Avenue, South Plainfield, NJ
The shop itself is nice, the prices aren’t the worst either compared to others in the area. I want to like this store so…
CardShopDir