60 shops in New York (NY) carry Magic: The Gathering.
Boardgame Bounty Hunters
5.0(48 reviews)
367 Windsor Highway, New Windsor, NY
Been going here since it opened last year, owner is super nice, participated in several D&D and paint and take events.…
Dork Forest Comics
5.0(43 reviews)
18 East Main Street, Clifton Springs, NY
Tucked away in Clifton Springs, this hidden gem draws devoted collectors and duelists despite being open just one day a…
Press Play Cards
5.0(27 reviews)
1323 East 15th Street, , NY
Nestled in the heart of New York, Press Play Cards is a welcoming haven for trading card enthusiasts, earning a flawless…
Shiny Cardboard and Collectibles TCG
5.0(25 reviews)
80 Smokey Hollow Road, Baldwinsville, NY
Tucked away in Baldwinsville, this gem of a shop has earned a perfect 5-star rating from 25 reviews for good reason. Tra…
High Noon Comics
5.0(24 reviews)
1821 New York 376, Poughkeepsie, NY
Your place for Comic Books, Action Figures, Trading Cards & More! Located in Poughkeepsie, NY.
CARDSMART
5.0(19 reviews)
3161 Amboy Road, , NY
Tucked away in New York, this trading card haven has earned a flawless 5-star rating from 19 reviews, and it’s easy to s…
Smoke and Mirrors Hobby
Top Rated4.9(278 reviews)
3 Brandywine Drive, Deer Park, NY
One stop shopping for your TCG needs! We provide competitive pricing, coupled with excellent service. Get a local LGS fe…
Lost4toys
Top Rated4.9(73 reviews)
267 Nassau Boulevard, Garden City South, NY
Lost 4 Toys is a one stop shop for all your superhero needs! Lost 4 Toys carries all types of superhero and movie items.
AAN Collect
Top Rated4.9(54 reviews)
40 Kellogg Road, New Hartford, NY
This is a family friendly place, our kids never want to leave and the staff have been absolutely wonderful with every fa…
Megaton Games
4.9(48 reviews)
2533 James Street, Syracuse, NY
Visiting from out of state. Cute shop on the smaller side, but had a pretty decent selection of games for various system…
From The Vault
4.9(47 reviews)
662 Old Liverpool Road, Liverpool, NY
Tucked away in Liverpool, NY, this gem of a shop is open just two days a week, making every visit feel like a special ev…
Land Before Time - Buy, Sell, Trade
4.9(43 reviews)
209 Oswego Street, Liverpool, NY
Tucked away in Liverpool, New York, this beloved local hub is a must-visit for anyone serious about trading cards. Consi…
Ret's Card Utopia
4.9(39 reviews)
811 Black River Boulevard, Rome, NY
Tucked away in Rome, NY, this gem of a shop has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from 39 reviews for good reason. Ret's…
LessGo!
4.9(38 reviews)
1012 Little Britain Road, New Windsor, NY
Tucked away in New Windsor, NY, this gem of a shop operates on a unique, limited schedule—open just two days a week—but…
Upstate Rc and Hobbies
4.9(30 reviews)
91 North Main Street, Gloversville, NY
Tucked into the heart of Gloversville, this is the kind of local spot where the dice rolls are lucky and the binders are…
Gametopia
4.9(28 reviews)
1900 Empire Boulevard, Webster, NY
There’s nothing better than cracking open a fresh game, rolling the perfect initiative, or pulling the card that turns t…
The Game Shoppe
Top Rated4.8(143 reviews)
11 East Pulteney Street, Corning, NY
The Game Shoppe is hands down one of the best places for Magic: The Gathering players, whether you’re a veteran or just…
Genesis Gaming & Hobby
Top Rated4.8(69 reviews)
8408 North Main Street, Eden, NY
Tucked away in Eden, NY, this community-driven spot is a haven for trading card enthusiasts. Genesis Gaming & Hobby offe…
Curiosity card and gifts
4.8(25 reviews)
193 Atlantic Avenue, Freeport, NY
Tucked away in Freeport, NY, this gem is a haven for players of Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and Riftbound.…
Frontier Games
4.8(23 reviews)
724 Manhattan Avenue, , NY
Your one stop shop for all things Tabletop, MTG, Pokémon, D&D, and more!
TheCardGuysLLC
4.8(17 reviews)
311 Sand Lane, , NY
Shop TheCardGuysLLC for the best selection of sealed sports and trading card boxes. Enjoy unbeatable prices, fast shippi…
Rip N Ship Gaming
Top Rated4.7(286 reviews)
1883 Unit B Deer Park Avenue, Deer Park, NY
We have migrated away from ripnshipsingles and will now be using Card Chaos! Hit the button below to register for an acc…
Genesis Comics and Gaming
Top Rated4.7(255 reviews)
600-26 Portion Road, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
New comics and a great selection of back issues and graded comic books. Second-to-none Magic the Gathering single selec…
Piece of the Game
Top Rated4.7(248 reviews)
1659 U.S. 9, Wappingers Falls, NY
Piece of the game l shop sports cards, gaming cards, and collectibles. "The apple store of card shops." A 5 star sport c…
Funky Town Collectibles
Top Rated4.7(95 reviews)
2394 Middle Country Road, Centereach, NY
From sports cards and memorabilia to Star Wars everything, Pokèmon cards, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic the gathering, and more. Funk…
Cinderella Card Shop
Top Rated4.7(93 reviews)
709 Manhattan Avenue, , NY
Step into a world of enchantment at Cinderella Card Store in NYC! From the moment you enter, you're greeted with a magic…
Piece of The Game
Top Rated4.7(78 reviews)
379 Tarrytown Road, White Plains, NY
Piece of the game l shop sports cards, gaming cards, and collectibles. "The apple store of card shops." A 5 star sport c…
World Champion Trading Cards
Top Rated4.7(68 reviews)
36-07 162nd Street, , NY
If your into trading card, this is a great place to visit. Friendly and enthusiastic, it was great to hang out and talk…
Top Cut Cards
Top Rated4.7(59 reviews)
43 Kelly Drive, Cheektowaga, NY
Just minutes from Buffalo, this Cheektowaga gem is a go-to spot for trading card enthusiasts. Whether you're hunting for…
Team Rocket TCG
Top Rated4.7(52 reviews)
159 Woods Avenue, Oceanside, NY
Team Rocket TCG is a trading card shop in Oceanside, NY, located at 159 Woods Avenue. The store carries Pokemon, Magic:…
House of Reeves
4.7(49 reviews)
243 East Main Street, Elbridge, NY
We offer a variety of Pokemon, Magic and other card games, in our collectible shop. Great prices, lightning fast delive…
Galaxy Comics II Bay Ridge
4.7(39 reviews)
6823 5th Avenue, , NY
Tucked away in Bay Ridge, this beloved local spot is a haven for trading card enthusiasts, earning a stellar 4.7-star ra…
Plunder Gaming
4.7(18 reviews)
2590 Riverfront Center, Amsterdam, NY
Tucked away in Amsterdam, NY, Plunder Gaming is a dedicated destination for Magic: The Gathering enthusiasts. This shop…
Zombie Planet
4.6(908 reviews)
1238 Central Avenue, Albany, NY
We specialize in roleplaying games, miniature games, collectible and non-collectible card games. We have a large assortm…
Comix Zone
4.6(357 reviews)
628 South Main Street, North Syracuse, NY
We have been the premier comic book specialty retailer in Central New York for over 26 years selling the absolute best i…
Flipside Gaming - East Greenbush
4.6(352 reviews)
598 Columbia Turnpike, East Greenbush, NY
Had such a great experience with my son at Flipside Gaming! The entire team was incredibly welcoming—especially Alex, th…
The Brooklyn Strategist
4.6(215 reviews)
333 Court Street, , NY
DO NOT BUY GAMES FROM HERE - they do not honor the return policy that is stated on the receipt. They will look for any o…
Ravenswood Comics
4.6(118 reviews)
8451 Seneca Turnpike, New Hartford, NY
Since 1983, Ravenswood Comics has been the CNY’s premier comics shop. Over 120,000 comics, tons of CCG, collectibles and…
Collect Binghamton by Piece of The Game
4.6(73 reviews)
174 Clinton Street, Binghamton, NY
John and everyone at Collect are fantastic to work with. Incredibly fair pricing with a great variety of sports and TCG…
Nerd Store
4.6(67 reviews)
50 Main Street, Mount Morris, NY
We almost missed it walking by, but it was full of young people playing board games. Seems like a great place to hang ou…
Topps by Dave & Adam's
4.6(47 reviews)
124 Main Street, Cooperstown, NY
Ignite a Burning Spirit of Battle! Celebrate the release of the new Pokémon set: Mega Evolution Phantasmal Flames Join…
Misfit Games
4.6(45 reviews)
157 East 1st Street, Oswego, NY
Met the wonderful people of Misfit Games at Retro Game Con in Syracuse. My boyfriend and I were on our way out and reali…
Dashop
4.5(512 reviews)
6A Elizabeth Street, New York, NY
Dashop is a trading card shop in New York, NY, located at 6A Elizabeth Street. The store carries Pokemon, Magic: The Gat…
Great Escape Adventures
4.5(457 reviews)
3300 Chambers Road, Horseheads, NY
My husband had heard many great things about Great Escape and we were finally able to stop in to check it out recently.…
Squiggy's Dugout
4.5(251 reviews)
237A East Main Street, New Rochelle, NY
Squiggys-Dugout is your go-to for comic books and gaming in New Rochelle. Discover new comics, collectible card games, a…
Champion Card Collector
4.5(200 reviews)
43 Vassar Road, Poughkeepsie, NY
For trading card enthusiasts in Poughkeepsie, this well-rated shop has you covered seven days a week. With a 4.5-star av…
Sanctuary Comics
4.5(160 reviews)
24764 New York 12, Watertown, NY
Tucked away in Watertown, New York, this local gem is a haven for Magic: The Gathering enthusiasts. With a solid 4.5-sta…
The Warp Game Store
4.5(126 reviews)
7806 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY
We carry Pro Acryl by Monument Hobbies, AK Interactive 3gen, Army Painter Warpaints Fanatic, Army Painter Speedpaint, Va…
The Collector's Friend
4.5(66 reviews)
528 3rd Avenue Extension, Rensselaer, NY
Huge Selection of Sports Cards For Sale. We carry packs and hobby boxes of Baseball Cards, Football Cards, Basketball Ca…
Upstate Sports Cards
4.5(58 reviews)
1094 Morton Boulevard, Kingston, NY
Tucked away in Kingston, this 4.5-star gem is a haven for collectors and players alike. Upstate Sports Cards offers a we…
Game On!!
4.5(38 reviews)
2670 Dewey Avenue, Rochester, NY
I'm not sure if it's a good or bad thing to have such an awesome card shop like this so close to my house. After being a…
Cards And Gifts 50% Off.
4.5(13 reviews)
262 Arden Avenue, , NY
Tucked away in New York, this destination for trading card enthusiasts offers deep discounts on Pokemon, Magic: The Gath…
Dave & Adam's Retail Store
4.4(1363 reviews)
8075 Sheridan Drive, Harris Hill, NY
Ignite a Burning Spirit of Battle! Celebrate the release of the new Pokémon set: Mega Evolution Phantasmal Flames Join…
Larger Than Life
4.4(526 reviews)
4100 New York 31, Clay, NY
The Big Toy Store in New York, Syracuse is Larger than Life Toys and Comics. We Carry the largest selection of collectib…
Flipside Gaming - Clifton Park
4.4(286 reviews)
1208 New York 146, , NY
Fast Shipping, Great Prices, Wide Selection. With a large array of games and collectibles, from the hottest titles to th…
Great Escape Adventures - Walden Galleria
4.4(78 reviews)
1 Walden Galleria, Buffalo, NY
Very nice layout and inventory of boardgames, card games, and Warhammer, however, the prices online do not match the pri…
Southern Tier Crossing
4.3(1245 reviews)
1-86 Ann Page Road, Horseheads, NY
Nestled in the heart of Horseheads, New York, this vibrant trading card destination has earned a solid 4.3-star rating f…
Larger Than Life
4.3(345 reviews)
9661 Destiny USA Drive, Syracuse, NY
The Big Toy Store in New York, Syracuse is Larger than Life Toys and Comics. We Carry the largest selection of collectib…
TreasureLand
4.3(73 reviews)
29 Broadway, Lynbrook, NY
Tucked away in Lynbrook, NY, this welcoming hub for trading card enthusiasts offers a solid selection of games that keep…
Genesis Comics and Gaming Patchogue
4.3(69 reviews)
580 Medford Avenue, Patchogue, NY
New comics and a great selection of back issues and graded comic books. Second-to-none Magic the Gathering single selec…
CardShopDir