Shop
726 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ 07002
ClosedClosed today
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely love Fantasy Bay! This is hands-down one of my favorite local spots in Bayonne. Whether you're into trading card games, board games, or collectibles, Fantasy Bay has it all. The store is super organized, clean, and welcoming—and the staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. They’re always happy to help whether you’re a beginner or a longtime collector. I’ve picked up some great finds here, and I love how they support the community with events and tournaments. It’s a perfect place to shop, hang out, or just browse if you're into anything fantasy, anime, or gaming related. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area!
40.6717961, -74.1114619
Open in Google Maps →
Manifest Comics
Top Rated4.7(224 reviews)
766 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ
The worker was very nice and gave my younger sister a free plush is a great local spot for all comic needs and trading c…
Mom and Pop Shop Collectibles LLC
4.6(34 reviews)
185 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ
Supporting a family-owned business run by a fellow Bayonne native is always a pleasure! This place truly has something s…
Sigma Games
14 Mountain Avenue, Bound Brook, NJ
Sigma Games is a trading card shop in Bound Brook, NJ, located at 14 Mountain Avenue. The store carries Pokemon, Magic:…
Monmouth Trading Cards
Top Rated5.0(475 reviews)
85 Godwin Avenue, Midland Park, NJ
Experience the premier destination for sports cards, memorabilia, and exclusive in-store events — designed for collector…
Bergen County Sports Cards
Top Rated5.0(232 reviews)
65A West Main Street, Bergenfield, NJ
The polls are now open for the 20th annual BEST of BERGEN readers’ poll. You can nominate businesses (or encourage other…
The Toy & Comic Spot
Top Rated5.0(167 reviews)
1889 New Jersey 88, Brick Township, NJ
Discover The Toy & Comic Spot – the ultimate comic book store Jersey Shore for back issues, graded comics, vintage toys,…
POKEBLITZ
Top Rated5.0(150 reviews)
2511 Fire Road, Egg Harbor Township, NJ
Nestled in Egg Harbor Township, this premier Pokemon destination has earned a flawless 5-star rating from 150 reviews. P…
Mr. E's Game World
Top Rated5.0(138 reviews)
18 Cross Keys Road, Berlin, NJ
Owner is very professional and knowledgeable about his store and the items in it. Very community focused. Will work with…
CardShopDir