60 shops in Indiana (IN) carry Magic: The Gathering.
Nerd Zone
Top Rated5.0(65 reviews)
1160 Southeast A Street, Linton, IN
Took my 6 year old son here to check out some Pokémon items for his 7th birthday coming up. I could not be more pleased…
Element Null Gaming
5.0(32 reviews)
80 South Main Street, Scottsburg, IN
By far THE best card shop around. I don’t only do they buy sell And trade cards and items from multiple different card…
FYC Comics
5.0(14 reviews)
118 North Michigan Street, Plymouth, IN
The owners and staff are amazing and welcoming! I have gone many times and plan to go even more. They have all your nerd…
Cricks Collection LLC
5.0(12 reviews)
421 Spring Street, Jeffersonville, IN
Tucked away in Jeffersonville, Indiana, this highly-rated trading card shop is a gem for collectors and players alike. I…
Discount Gaming
Top Rated4.9(153 reviews)
2548 Arthur Street, Gary, IN
With a stellar 4.9-star rating from over 150 reviews, this Gary, Indiana gem is a haven for trading card enthusiasts. Di…
Nerdy Ape Gaming
Top Rated4.9(139 reviews)
Commerce Drive, Lafayette, IN
In Lafayette, Indiana, trading card enthusiasts have found a true gem for their hobby. This local shop offers a vibrant…
Rainer's Poké Stop
Top Rated4.9(101 reviews)
3540 State Route 38, Lafayette, IN
Tucked away in Lafayette, Indiana, this hidden gem has earned a perfect 4.9-star rating from over 100 reviews. Despite b…
Toy Buzz & Fizz
Top Rated4.9(75 reviews)
1702 East Main Street, Plainfield, IN
Whether you're hunting for rare Pokémon cards, fine-tuning a competitive Magic: The Gathering deck, or diving into the n…
Toys in the Attic - Crown Point
4.9(27 reviews)
1 Courthouse Square, Crown Point, IN
Northwest Indiana toy stores specializing in toys and games that empower children through creativity, imagination, and f…
Summit Comics & Games
4.9(13 reviews)
4201 Coldwater Road, Fort Wayne, IN
Fort Wayne's home for comic books, board games, sports memorabilia, card games, Magic the Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh, Pokemon,…
Hoosier Daddies Cards, Games, and More
Top Rated4.8(82 reviews)
1121 16th Street, Bedford, IN
Tucked away in Bedford, IN, this gem of a game store offers a welcoming space for trading card enthusiasts of all levels…
Warhammer
Top Rated4.8(74 reviews)
1740 Apple Glen Boulevard, Fort Wayne, IN
Collect, build, and paint miniatures, and fight strategic tabletop battles. The best hobby in the world is waiting for y…
Savage
4.8(48 reviews)
111 East Market Street, Nappanee, IN
Hidden away in Nappanee, Indiana, this trading card gem opens its doors just one day a week, making every visit feel lik…
Moonshot Games
Top Rated4.7(524 reviews)
50 North 9th Street, Noblesville, IN
Game store and toy store in historic downtown Noblesville, IN. We specialize in Board Games, Magic the Gathering (MtG),…
The Castle Games
Top Rated4.7(100 reviews)
210 West 2nd Street, Seymour, IN
Buy Magic: The Gathering, Lorcana, Singles, Pokémon, Digimon TCG, One Piece. Booster Boxes, Packs, Commander, Warhammer,…
Moonshot Games - Plainfield
Top Rated4.7(76 reviews)
1620 East Main Street, Plainfield, IN
Tucked away in Plainfield, Indiana, this local gem has earned a stellar 4.7-star rating from 76 reviews for good reason.…
Card Craze
Top Rated4.7(53 reviews)
4629 West Richland Plaza Drive, Bloomington, IN
Tucked into Bloomington’s vibrant scene, this is the go-to spot for players who take their cardboard seriously. It’s a h…
Michiana Sports Cards
4.7(48 reviews)
12980 Adams Road, Granger, IN
Michiana Sports Cards is the newest hobby shop in the South Bend area! Visit us today for hobby boxes, retail boxes and…
Main Phase One
4.7(45 reviews)
999 North Congress Avenue, Evansville, IN
Nestled in Evansville, Indiana, this well-rated local hub offers a focused selection of trading card games including Lor…
Lost and Found Toys
4.7(16 reviews)
113 West 2nd Street, Seymour, IN
After going to a local community comic book event, my wife and I decided to drive around to local shops. We found this l…
Fantasy Games
4.6(594 reviews)
52025 State Highway 933, South Bend, IN
Fantasy Games - Magic the Gathering, Miniatures Games, Board Games and RPGs
Galactic Greg's
4.6(438 reviews)
1407 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN
Galactic Greg's has been in business for over 30 years! We pride ourselves in our quality customer service and products…
Tier 1 Games
4.6(292 reviews)
2200 Elmwood Avenue, Lafayette, IN
Here you’ll find a welcoming space to connect, play and make new friends. Whether you’re browsing our selection of table…
The Sage's Shoppe
4.6(281 reviews)
1009 Sagamore Parkway West, West Lafayette, IN
Physical Address: The Sage's Shoppe Gaming and Tournament Center 1009 Sagamore Parkway West West Lafayette, IN 47906 t/f…
Blue Moon Comic Strikes Back
4.6(110 reviews)
2405 South Earl Avenue, Lafayette, IN
Tucked away in Lafayette, Indiana, this local gem punches above its weight for trading card enthusiasts. Blue Moon Comic…
The Castle Games
4.6(99 reviews)
2191 State Street, Columbus, IN
This is my favorite place in town for cards. They give fair prices for things you bring in. The staff is very welcoming…
Dungeon Gaming
4.6(58 reviews)
2020 South Western Avenue, Marion, IN
Tucked away in Marion, Indiana, Dungeon Gaming is a 4.6-star haven for trading card enthusiasts, backed by nearly 60 pos…
Schmoley's Gaming Cave Cafe
4.5(20 reviews)
102 North Main Street, Crown Point, IN
Tucked away in Crown Point, Indiana, this cozy spot is a haven for trading card enthusiasts despite its limited hours—op…
Savini Comics
4.5(15 reviews)
430 East Broadway, Logansport, IN
Nestled in Logansport, Indiana, this trading card destination offers a focused selection of games including Pokemon, Mag…
The Castle Games
4.5(14 reviews)
202 West Temperance Street, Ellettsville, IN
Buy Magic: The Gathering, Lorcana, Singles, Pokémon, Digimon TCG, One Piece. Booster Boxes, Packs, Commander, Warhammer,…
K & L Cards
4.4(132 reviews)
3100 Meridian Parke Drive, Greenwood, IN
Welcome to K & L Cards, your premier destination for all things related to trading cards and collectibles in Greenwood,…
Instant Cash 4 Gift Cards
4.4(16 reviews)
3930 Main Street, East Chicago, IN
In East Chicago, Indiana, trading card enthusiasts and collectors will find a reliable spot for Pokemon, Magic: The Gath…
Valparaiso Marketplace
4.3(971 reviews)
2410 Laporte Avenue, Valparaiso, IN
Just off the beaten path in Valparaiso, Indiana, this welcoming trading card hub draws in players and collectors with a…
Media Exchange
4.3(388 reviews)
1234 Johnson Street, Elkhart, IN
Tucked away in Elkhart, Indiana, Media Exchange is a go-to spot for trading card enthusiasts looking to build their coll…
Full Moon Games
4.3(203 reviews)
248 South 7th Street, Terre Haute, IN
We appreciate you! Be sure to Check Out with In-Store Pick-Up in advance to get your singles when you arrive to the shop…
Next Level Games LLC
4.3(127 reviews)
406 East McGalliard Road, Muncie, IN
Tucked away in Muncie, Indiana, this compact destination punches well above its weight for trading card enthusiasts. Des…
Four Sharp Corners
4.3(51 reviews)
218 East Main Street, Greenfield, IN
Nestled in Greenfield, Indiana, this welcoming hub for trading card enthusiasts offers a solid selection of Pokémon, Mag…
Jasper Swap Shop
4.2(24 reviews)
495 Third Avenue, Jasper, IN
Located in the heart of Jasper, Indiana, this local favorite offers a solid mix of trading cards for collectors and play…
Baseball Card Exchange
4.0(251 reviews)
709b U.S. 41, Schererville, IN
Baseball Card Exchange started authenticating full unopened boxes in 2007 and full unopened cases in 2015. Get your unop…
Montgomery County Fairgrounds
4.0(69 reviews)
400 Parke Avenue, Crawfordsville, IN
Tucked into the Montgomery County Fairgrounds in Crawfordsville, Indiana, this trading card hotspot draws players and co…
Conquest Cards
4.0(15 reviews)
7483 East US Highway 36, Avon, IN
Tucked away in Avon, Indiana, this compact shop is a haven for trading card enthusiasts. Conquest Cards specializes in P…
Play at the Plate Cards & Games
200 South Green River Road, Evansville, IN
Play at the Plate Cards & Games is a trading card shop in Evansville, IN, located at 200 South Green River Road. The sto…
Casket City Games
312 South Eastern Avenue, Batesville, IN
Casket City Games is a trading card shop in Batesville, IN, located at 312 South Eastern Avenue. The store carries Pokem…
Timmys Card Castle
117 East Center Street, Bourbon, IN
Timmys Card Castle is a trading card shop in Bourbon, IN, located at 117 East Center Street. The store carries Pokemon,…
Escape TCG & More LLC
Top Rated5.0(103 reviews)
305b North Main Street, Liberty, IN
Pokémon, MTG, Lorcana & more! We offer a wide variety of TCGs for all current and new sets!
Gone Lucid Games
5.0(10 reviews)
708 East 3rd Street, Clinton, IN
BEAUTIFUL SHOP! Awesome event space with with ample room to play games. They stock Pokemon, Magic the gathering, One Pie…
Game Plan
5.0(6 reviews)
450 Main Street, Montgomery, IN
Game Plan is a trading card shop in Montgomery, IN, located at 450 Main Street. The store carries Pokemon, Magic: The Ga…
Top Flight Gaming
5.0(4 reviews)
3175 South 3rd Place, Terre Haute, IN
Top Flight Gaming is a trading card shop in Terre Haute, IN, located at 3175 South 3rd Place. The store carries Pokemon,…
The ReCollectiverse
5.0(4 reviews)
1324 North Fares Avenue, Evansville, IN
This store is pretty awesome! They have priced books, dollar books, toys, games, and tons of other media fun stuff! They…
And 1 Cards
5.0(1 reviews)
413 West 1st Street, New Albany, IN
Buy and sell electronics, cars, fashion apparel, collectibles, sporting goods, digital cameras, baby items, coupons, and…
The yeep brothers
5.0(1 reviews)
623 South Dean Place, Rensselaer, IN
The yeep brothers is a trading card shop in Rensselaer, IN, located at 623 South Dean Place. The store carries Pokemon,…
Storming Good Games
5.0(1 reviews)
22 East Washington Street, Greencastle, IN
Game and card shop opening soon at 22 E Washington Street, Greencastle, IN 46145
Take Action Tattoo and Gaming
Top Rated4.9(181 reviews)
938 North Detroit Street, Warsaw, IN
Jean has walk-ins available till 6pm. First come first serve. you can call the shop 574-267-4284 if you wanna check but…
The Rock Shop
4.9(15 reviews)
608 North Street, Logansport, IN
The Rock Shop is a trading card shop in Logansport, IN, located at 608 North Street. The store carries Pokemon, Magic: T…
Valkyrie's Vault
Top Rated4.8(333 reviews)
1044 East Main Street, Brownsburg, IN
mannn talk about a STEAL!!! we aren't huge on tabletop gaming but there's ALWAYS something cool to find here - and today…
The Common Room
Top Rated4.8(206 reviews)
223 South Pete Ellis Drive, Bloomington, IN
The Common Room is a trading card shop in Bloomington, IN, located at 223 South Pete Ellis Drive. The store carries Lorc…
By The Board Games & Entertainment
Top Rated4.8(184 reviews)
410 East Commercial Avenue, Lowell, IN
Board Games, Dice Games, Card Games, Trading Card Games, Gifts, Events
Krypton Comics
Top Rated4.8(131 reviews)
77 East Washington Street, Martinsville, IN
Your family friendly, locally owned comic book and gaming store!
Game Knight
Top Rated4.8(87 reviews)
2867 North Newton Street, Jasper, IN
Game Knight is a trading card shop in Jasper, IN, located at 2867 North Newton Street. The store carries Pokemon, Magic:…
dragons castle gaming
4.8(19 reviews)
1523 South F Street, Elwood, IN
dragons castle gaming is a trading card shop in Elwood, IN, located at 1523 South F Street. The store carries Pokemon, M…
CardShopDir