IN Card Shop Directory
Hoosier State, Hobby Heroes
202
Shops Listed
85
Cities
4.6★
Avg Rating
24,540
Total Reviews
Indiana's trading card scene spans Pokémon leagues, Magic: The Gathering tournaments, Yu-Gi-Oh! events, and a deep sports card culture. Hoosier State collectors will find everything from the latest sealed product and singles to vintage wax, PSA grading drop-offs, and Japanese imports. Our directory covers 202 listed shops, 85 cities, an average rating of 4.6 stars, 24,540+ collector reviews. The most popular games among Indiana's shops are Pokemon (106 shops), Magic: The Gathering (77 shops), Yu-Gi-Oh! (72 shops), reflecting the state's diverse collector community. Major hubs include Evansville, Fort Wayne, Indianapolis, and their surrounding suburbs, each with its own mix of TCG specialty stores, sports card vaults, and comic shops. Whether you're chasing a rookie card, hunting alt-art Pokémon, or building your first Commander deck, Indiana's card shops deliver knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and a welcoming community for collectors at every level.
Need a card shop in another area? Find card shops near you.
Showing 60 shops in Indiana
Nerd Zone
Top Rated5.0(65 reviews)
1160 Southeast A Street, Linton, IN
Took my 6 year old son here to check out some Pokémon items for his 7th birthday coming up. I could not be more pleased…
The Trainer Pack
5.0(48 reviews)
12980 Adams Road, Granger, IN
We drove an hour to come and check this place our! We loved it, and we will gladly drive again. Amazing selection, good…
Element Null Gaming
5.0(32 reviews)
80 South Main Street, Scottsburg, IN
By far THE best card shop around. I don’t only do they buy sell And trade cards and items from multiple different card…
BigKidBrix, LLC.
5.0(28 reviews)
1615 West Coliseum Boulevard, Fort Wayne, IN
As a Lego fan having this store here in town is so cool. We were immediately greeted with a smile at the door and promp…
Play Test Lounge
5.0(26 reviews)
2176 East 116th Street, Carmel, IN
We invite you to our social gaming theme park Play Test Lounge, where fun and connection thrive. Join us now.
Card Guys Sports Cards
5.0(24 reviews)
413 Main Street, Jasper, IN
If you are looking for a unique gift, this is the place to be! The staff can guide you through all types of cards, from…
KeyCards LLC
5.0(19 reviews)
409 Spring Street, Jeffersonville, IN
Thrilled to have a fantastic new Hobby Shop in downtown Jeff that carries such a huge variety of Sports cards! They trul…
The Poke Den
5.0(19 reviews)
2605 Decio Drive, Elkhart, IN
Tucked away in Elkhart, Indiana, The Poke Den is a dedicated haven for Pokémon trading card enthusiasts. This shop focus…
RS Sports Cards
5.0(19 reviews)
202b Walnut Street, Lawrenceburg, IN
Sports Cards Custom Apparel Amsoil Store front coming soon in Lawrenceburg,IN
FYC Comics
5.0(14 reviews)
118 North Michigan Street, Plymouth, IN
The owners and staff are amazing and welcoming! I have gone many times and plan to go even more. They have all your nerd…
West Side Trading Cards
5.0(14 reviews)
5225 Pearl Drive, Evansville, IN
West Side Trading Cards is the best place to find sports memorabilia, signed jerseys, helmets, cards, and more! Visit ou…
Uptown Sports Cards
5.0(13 reviews)
25 East George Street, Batesville, IN
Vintage and high-end sports cards and collectibles
Cricks Collection LLC
5.0(12 reviews)
421 Spring Street, Jeffersonville, IN
Tucked away in Jeffersonville, Indiana, this highly-rated trading card shop is a gem for collectors and players alike. I…
Sidelines Sports Cards
5.0(11 reviews)
140 East Main Street, Cambridge City, IN
Tucked away in the heart of Cambridge City, Indiana, this hidden gem is a must-visit for any sports card enthusiast. Sid…
The Hobby Den
Top Rated4.9(595 reviews)
5432 East Indiana Street, Evansville, IN
Tucked away in Evansville, Indiana, this gem of a shop is a must-visit for any Pokémon trading card enthusiast. The Hobb…
Discount Gaming
Top Rated4.9(153 reviews)
2548 Arthur Street, Gary, IN
With a stellar 4.9-star rating from over 150 reviews, this Gary, Indiana gem is a haven for trading card enthusiasts. Di…
Nerdy Ape Gaming
Top Rated4.9(139 reviews)
Commerce Drive, Lafayette, IN
In Lafayette, Indiana, trading card enthusiasts have found a true gem for their hobby. This local shop offers a vibrant…
CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING
Top Rated4.9(103 reviews)
900 Tutor Lane, Evansville, IN
Shop the largest selection of trading cards & join exciting events. Visit us for tournaments & trade nights!
Rainer's Poké Stop
Top Rated4.9(101 reviews)
3540 State Route 38, Lafayette, IN
Tucked away in Lafayette, Indiana, this hidden gem has earned a perfect 4.9-star rating from over 100 reviews. Despite b…
Faraday Toys
Top Rated4.9(87 reviews)
350 South Madison Avenue, Greenwood, IN
Tucked away in Greenwood, Indiana, this gem of a shop offers an electric atmosphere for Dragon Ball Super fans. With a s…
Toy Buzz & Fizz
Top Rated4.9(75 reviews)
1702 East Main Street, Plainfield, IN
Whether you're hunting for rare Pokémon cards, fine-tuning a competitive Magic: The Gathering deck, or diving into the n…
Mascot Sports Cards & Collectibles
Top Rated4.9(59 reviews)
705 Main Street, Tell City, IN
Our 2 families wandered in looking for pokemon cards and they delivered. Lots of neat collectibles also. We stayed all…
Underground Case Breaks
Top Rated4.9(53 reviews)
206 Main Street, Hobart, IN
Buy sports cards, Pokémon, and TCG products. Join live group breaks or shop sealed boxes and singles from trusted brands…
All Star Sports Cards
4.9(34 reviews)
2170 West White River Boulevard, Muncie, IN
Tucked away in Muncie, this spot has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from 34 reviews for good reason. All Star Sports C…
Toys in the Attic - Crown Point
4.9(27 reviews)
1 Courthouse Square, Crown Point, IN
Northwest Indiana toy stores specializing in toys and games that empower children through creativity, imagination, and f…
LA Comics and Collectibles
4.9(20 reviews)
10 East Broadway Street, Shelbyville, IN
This local card/toy shop is exactly what every collector hopes to find. The owner is super friendly, knowledgeable, and…
Three Strikes Sports Cards & Hobby
4.9(17 reviews)
413 South Tillotson Avenue, Muncie, IN
Tucked away in Muncie, Indiana, this gem has become a go‑to for sports card collectors. With a stellar 4.9‑star rating f…
Summit Comics & Games
4.9(13 reviews)
4201 Coldwater Road, Fort Wayne, IN
Fort Wayne's home for comic books, board games, sports memorabilia, card games, Magic the Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh, Pokemon,…
Hometown Hobby Sports Cards and More
4.9(11 reviews)
1211 I Avenue, New Castle, IN
Tucked away in New Castle, Indiana, this top-rated spot is a haven for sports card collectors. With a stellar 4.9-star r…
Horse Saddle Shop
Top Rated4.8(369 reviews)
1205 West Plymouth Street, Bremen, IN
Worked with Josh on multiple occasions. Fast response, thorough on answers, hassle free. This place was great! Came back…
Indy Card Exchange
Top Rated4.8(335 reviews)
7035 East 96th Street, Indianapolis, IN
Have a child 13 & Under that is into collecting cards? Consider signing them up for the Indy Card Exchange Kids Club! Ou…
Mage's Comics and Games
Top Rated4.8(140 reviews)
7623 Shelby Street, Indianapolis, IN
One of the biggest, widest selection of comic books I've been to locally. Definitely one of my favorites specifically fo…
More Fun Sports Cards
Top Rated4.8(116 reviews)
706 Joliet Street, Dyer, IN
From high end product and memorabilia to your penny cards this is my favorite card shop around. Always a family friendly…
Upscale Trading Cards
Top Rated4.8(107 reviews)
3830 North First Avenue, Evansville, IN
Welcome to Upscale trading cards Football Basketball Baseball Soccer UFC Wwe Pokémon Hockey
Hoosier Daddies Cards, Games, and More
Top Rated4.8(82 reviews)
1121 16th Street, Bedford, IN
Tucked away in Bedford, IN, this gem of a game store offers a welcoming space for trading card enthusiasts of all levels…
Warhammer
Top Rated4.8(74 reviews)
1740 Apple Glen Boulevard, Fort Wayne, IN
Collect, build, and paint miniatures, and fight strategic tabletop battles. The best hobby in the world is waiting for y…
Sport Stop
Top Rated4.8(54 reviews)
655 W State St, Fremont, IN
In the heart of Fremont, Indiana, a dedicated community of duelists has found its home. Known for a stellar 4.8-star rat…
Savage
4.8(48 reviews)
111 East Market Street, Nappanee, IN
Hidden away in Nappanee, Indiana, this trading card gem opens its doors just one day a week, making every visit feel lik…
Cubs Den
4.8(27 reviews)
420 South William Street, South Bend, IN
Visiting from Canada with a friend to see family and give him a tour of Chicago, he was kind enough to add a new destina…
Mineral City Cards LLC
4.8(13 reviews)
340 West Morgan Street, Martinsville, IN
Tucked away in Martinsville, Indiana, this locally loved sports card shop has earned a stellar 4.8-star rating from 13 r…
Moonshot Games
Top Rated4.7(524 reviews)
50 North 9th Street, Noblesville, IN
Game store and toy store in historic downtown Noblesville, IN. We specialize in Board Games, Magic the Gathering (MtG),…
Hometown Comics & Games
Top Rated4.7(519 reviews)
1040 North State Street, Greenfield, IN
This is one of the better game stores I have been to. The staff alone make it worthy of a 5 star review. They are kind,…
The Gaming Guild
Top Rated4.7(453 reviews)
1460 North Green River Road, Evansville, IN
Gaming Guild, board games, magic the gathering, magic, RPG, game supplies, game store, pre-release, minis, dice, paint,…
Saltire Toys & Games
Top Rated4.7(309 reviews)
11135 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN
We’ve been going to them for years for presents for our young kids as well as others. It truly feels like the games and…
The Castle Games
Top Rated4.7(100 reviews)
210 West 2nd Street, Seymour, IN
Buy Magic: The Gathering, Lorcana, Singles, Pokémon, Digimon TCG, One Piece. Booster Boxes, Packs, Commander, Warhammer,…
Moonshot Games - Plainfield
Top Rated4.7(76 reviews)
1620 East Main Street, Plainfield, IN
Tucked away in Plainfield, Indiana, this local gem has earned a stellar 4.7-star rating from 76 reviews for good reason.…
Busby's Cards and Collectibles
Top Rated4.7(53 reviews)
1410 Charlestown New Albany Road, Jeffersonville, IN
Our daughter loves Magic and Pokemon cards. Busbys has a very nice selection. He's very busy it's takes a little bit bef…
Card Craze
Top Rated4.7(53 reviews)
4629 West Richland Plaza Drive, Bloomington, IN
Tucked into Bloomington’s vibrant scene, this is the go-to spot for players who take their cardboard seriously. It’s a h…
Michiana Sports Cards
4.7(48 reviews)
12980 Adams Road, Granger, IN
Michiana Sports Cards is the newest hobby shop in the South Bend area! Visit us today for hobby boxes, retail boxes and…
Steves Hobby World
4.7(46 reviews)
418B Sagamore Parkway North, Lafayette, IN
Tucked away in Lafayette, Indiana, this local gem has become a go-to destination for trading card enthusiasts, especiall…
Main Phase One
4.7(45 reviews)
999 North Congress Avenue, Evansville, IN
Nestled in Evansville, Indiana, this well-rated local hub offers a focused selection of trading card games including Lor…
Pop Culture
4.7(43 reviews)
100 Lighthouse Place, Michigan City, IN
Your Ultimate Shop for Funko Pops, Pokemon, Statues & Graphic Tees. Find Rare Exclusives, Premium Figures & Official Ap…
Hoosier Sports Cards
4.7(34 reviews)
19 North Court Street, Sullivan, IN
Very fortunate to have a local sports card shop as amazing as Hoosier Sports Cards. I have always been a huge fan of the…
Lost and Found Toys
4.7(16 reviews)
113 West 2nd Street, Seymour, IN
After going to a local community comic book event, my wife and I decided to drive around to local shops. We found this l…
Vintage Indy Sports
4.7(15 reviews)
1450 North Main Street, Speedway, IN
Vintage sports memorabilia with a focus on Indiana High School Basketball, Indianapolis Colts, Indiana Pacers, Indiana U…
Fantasy Games
4.6(594 reviews)
52025 State Highway 933, South Bend, IN
Fantasy Games - Magic the Gathering, Miniatures Games, Board Games and RPGs
Galactic Greg's
4.6(438 reviews)
1407 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN
Galactic Greg's has been in business for over 30 years! We pride ourselves in our quality customer service and products…
Tier 1 Games
4.6(292 reviews)
2200 Elmwood Avenue, Lafayette, IN
Here you’ll find a welcoming space to connect, play and make new friends. Whether you’re browsing our selection of table…
The Sage's Shoppe
4.6(281 reviews)
1009 Sagamore Parkway West, West Lafayette, IN
Physical Address: The Sage's Shoppe Gaming and Tournament Center 1009 Sagamore Parkway West West Lafayette, IN 47906 t/f…
Blue Moon Comic Strikes Back
4.6(110 reviews)
2405 South Earl Avenue, Lafayette, IN
Tucked away in Lafayette, Indiana, this local gem punches above its weight for trading card enthusiasts. Blue Moon Comic…
Indiana has 202 trading card shops listed in our directory across 85 cities, with an average rating of 4.6 stars.
Indiana's card shops carry a wide range of TCG and sports card products, with the most popular being Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!. You'll find stores specializing in Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports cards, and more.
The cities with the most card shops in Indiana are Evansville (12), Fort Wayne (12), Indianapolis (10).
Browse our directory by city above, or use the search bar to find card shops in your area. Each listing includes store hours, ratings, directions, and the games they carry.
CardShopDir