WI Card Shop Directory
Badger State, Binder Badgers
226
Shops Listed
99
Cities
4.6★
Avg Rating
30,029
Total Reviews
Wisconsin's trading card scene spans Pokémon leagues, Magic: The Gathering tournaments, Yu-Gi-Oh! events, and a deep sports card culture. Badger State collectors will find everything from the latest sealed product and singles to vintage wax, PSA grading drop-offs, and Japanese imports. Our directory covers 226 listed shops, 99 cities, an average rating of 4.6 stars, 30,029+ collector reviews. The most popular games among Wisconsin's shops are Pokemon (107 shops), Magic: The Gathering (92 shops), Yu-Gi-Oh! (82 shops), reflecting the state's diverse collector community. Major hubs include Appleton, Eau Claire, Madison, and their surrounding suburbs, each with its own mix of TCG specialty stores, sports card vaults, and comic shops. Whether you're chasing a rookie card, hunting alt-art Pokémon, or building your first Commander deck, Wisconsin's card shops deliver knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and a welcoming community for collectors at every level.
Need a card shop in another area? Find card shops near you.
Showing 60 shops in Wisconsin
The Crimson Guild
Top Rated5.0(239 reviews)
8730 West North Avenue, Wauwatosa, WI
FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $300 FOR USA ONLY! Please join our discord channel https://discord.gg/psYXKydrVc
Three Mountain Games
5.0(28 reviews)
46 East Main Street, Reedsburg, WI
Three Mountain Games is Reedsburg’s friendly board game store—offering Magic: The Gathering, RPGs, family games, and gam…
Mega Media Xchange Janesville
5.0(24 reviews)
1323 Creston Park Drive, Janesville, WI
Our team is made up of passionate gamers who are dedicated to providing excellent service and expertise to our customers…
Allegedly Collectable
5.0(19 reviews)
930 Galloway Street, Eau Claire, WI
Tucked away in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, this gem of a trading card shop offers a focused selection of Pokemon and Flesh an…
2 Time Toys
5.0(19 reviews)
127 4th Street, Baraboo, WI
Tucked in Baraboo, Wisconsin, this five-star shop is a go-to destination for trading card fans. With a perfect 5/5 ratin…
On Track RC Hobbies & Raceway LLC
5.0(17 reviews)
805 Monroe Street, Sheboygan Falls, WI
Nestled in the heart of Sheboygan Falls, this hobby hotspot brings together the thrill of RC racing and a solid selectio…
AI Trading Card Gallery
5.0(14 reviews)
716 Ohio Street, Oshkosh, WI
By far one of the best places to get your singles, slabs, and prices! They usually have products most other stores don't…
Slick Mimic's
5.0(12 reviews)
792 West Northland Avenue, Appleton, WI
Hands down one of the best places in Wisconsin. This place is such an absolutely stellar store. Ultimately what makes Sl…
The Sanctum Tabletop Gaming Emporium
Top Rated4.9(311 reviews)
4615 Washington Avenue, Racine, WI
A friendly local games store in southeastern Wisconsin
Planet Chaos
Top Rated4.9(224 reviews)
1117 Whitewater Avenue, Fort Atkinson, WI
Tucked away in Fort Atkinson, this local hotspot has earned a near-perfect 4.9-star rating from over 220 reviews, and it…
MissingNo. Games
Top Rated4.9(175 reviews)
633 North Westhill Boulevard, Appleton, WI
A Local Trading Shop in the Appleton, WI area that specializes in Pokemon, One Piece, and Lorcana Trading Card Games!
Imperial Games
Top Rated4.9(144 reviews)
8633 West Greenfield Avenue, West Allis, WI
Stopped by recently to check out their board game selection and to see the new remodel. The first floor now sports all o…
Cardboard Legacy
Top Rated4.9(128 reviews)
923 Oregon Street, Oshkosh, WI
In the heart of Oshkosh, Wisconsin, a dedicated hub for trading card enthusiasts has earned an outstanding 4.9-star rati…
Jeff's Sports, Inc.
Top Rated4.9(104 reviews)
14165 West Capitol Drive, Brookfield, WI
Tucked away in Brookfield, Wisconsin, this gem has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from over 100 reviews. Jeff's Sports…
BB Sports Cards & TCG
Top Rated4.9(102 reviews)
2310 West College Avenue, Appleton, WI
BB Sports Cards is a family owned and operated business. We buy, sell, and trade!
Old Guard Games
Top Rated4.9(71 reviews)
3132 North Downer Avenue, Milwaukee, WI
Just found out about this awesome little gem of a shop. It’s definitely stocked with more rpg than regular board games,…
Beckett Castle TCG LLC
Top Rated4.9(60 reviews)
2525 3 Mile Road, Racine, WI
Hands down the best local TCG shop in Caledonia! Great friendly staff, great environment for players of all ages, and gr…
Slab Factory - Sports and Trading Cards
Top Rated4.9(57 reviews)
2527 East Clairemont Avenue, Eau Claire, WI
Sports Card and TCG Shop In Eau Claire Wisconsin. Specializing in Sports, Packers cards, Brewers, Bucks, Pokemon, One Pi…
Campaign Plus
Top Rated4.9(53 reviews)
208 East Chestnut Street, Burlington, WI
Tucked in Burlington, Wisconsin, this gem of a trading card shop has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from 53 reviews—an…
Four Myths Games and Hobby
4.9(39 reviews)
112 South Main Street, Waupaca, WI
Nestled in Waupaca, Wisconsin, a hidden gem for trading card enthusiasts opens its doors just two days a week—and those…
E-5 Sports
4.9(39 reviews)
7241 West Greenfield Avenue, West Allis, WI
We specialize in authentic autographs, sports trading cards and supplies, autograph signings and bobbleheads.
Valhalla Hobby
4.9(34 reviews)
535 Half Mile Road, Verona, WI
Small Space, Epic Inventory Good selection of miniatures and paints for a small storefront. Had the Tamiya glue I wante…
Undercity Games
4.9(33 reviews)
930 Galloway Street, Eau Claire, WI
Prizing: 2 Phantasmal Flames Booster Packs, 1 Play! Pokemon Series 7 Prize Pack for participating 1 Phantasmal Flames Bu…
Jay's Sport and Hobby
4.9(13 reviews)
1021 North Superior Avenue, Tomah, WI
I've been collecting sports cards for over 30 years, and my 9-year-old son has recently caught the bug as well. Our exp…
Adventure Games and Hobby
Top Rated4.8(554 reviews)
408 North Main Street, Oshkosh, WI
My boyfriend and I came in for the League of Legends Riftbound- Learn to Play night and had an amazing experience. We ca…
Badger Breaks / Badger Sports Shop
Top Rated4.8(105 reviews)
336 2nd Avenue South, Onalaska, WI
Bringing you the best, new, and exciting ways to collect your favorite teams or players!
Game Universe - Mequon
Top Rated4.8(102 reviews)
10954 North Port Washington Road, Mequon, WI
GU is everything you’d want from your local game store. Great selection of games and tcg singles. The staff is welcoming…
Just Imagine Toys
Top Rated4.8(99 reviews)
120 4th Avenue, Baraboo, WI
Really fun toy store! We stopped here on our way home from our trip to the Dells. Great selection for all ages of kids.…
Game Haven
Top Rated4.8(86 reviews)
229 South Century Avenue, Waunakee, WI
We have been so excited looking forward to this game store opening in Waunakee. We were able to come by for a few of the…
Fox Cities Cards
Top Rated4.8(77 reviews)
1881 North Casaloma Drive, Appleton, WI
Tucked away in Appleton, Wisconsin, this gem of a shop has earned a stellar 4.8-star rating from 77 reviews, and a visit…
Play Unplugged - Ashland
Top Rated4.8(73 reviews)
307 Main Street West, Ashland, WI
Tucked away in downtown Ashland, this inviting shop is a must-visit for trading card enthusiasts. Play Unplugged offers…
Atlas Gaming
Top Rated4.8(72 reviews)
21 North Main Street, Fond du Lac, WI
Your friendly neighborhood trading card game haven specializing in Magic, Pokémon, and Yu-Gi-Oh!
Magic Man Games
Top Rated4.8(59 reviews)
58 North Brown Street, Rhinelander, WI
Tucked away in Rhinelander, Wisconsin, this gem of a shop is a must-visit for trading card enthusiasts—but only if you t…
Cardboard Empires
4.8(49 reviews)
N136W21933 Bonniwell Road, Richfield, WI
Deep in the heart of Richfield, a dedicated trading card community gathers at a spot that’s earned a stellar 4.8-star ra…
Collectors Asylum
4.8(44 reviews)
20549 West Main Street, Lannon, WI
Tucked away in the quiet village of Lannon, Wisconsin, this welcoming spot has earned a stellar 4.8-star rating from 44…
Baraboo Vintage & Seek Boutique
4.8(31 reviews)
126 Water Street, Baraboo, WI
Tucked into the heart of downtown Baraboo, this charming spot blends nostalgia with modern tabletop fun. Baraboo Vintage…
Graden Cards LLC
4.8(27 reviews)
233 Kensington Drive, Madison, WI
Discover a wide range of sports cards and memorabilia at Graden Cards LLC. We specialize in selling and consigning uniqu…
TalonSong Gaming LLC
4.8(25 reviews)
225 Front Street, Minocqua, WI
What a great local game store! The perfect confluence of a family run business with excellent products and a very profe…
Steve Schmitt's Sports Treasures Plus
4.8(24 reviews)
1016 Nygaard Street, Stoughton, WI
Tucked away in Stoughton, Wisconsin, this gem of a card shop has earned a stellar 4.8-star rating from 24 local collecto…
Phoenix Haven Cards and Games
4.8(21 reviews)
315 East Main Street, Watertown, WI
Event List Click here to view our full event calendar Weekly Events Monday530PM - 9PMFlesh and Blood Armory Tuesday530PM…
Fit N Fun Games
4.8(11 reviews)
814 Crimson Valley Road, Hudson, WI
Fit N Fun Games is a board game that combines exercise, competition, and teamwork to make exercise a fun activity the wh…
Freaktoyz
Top Rated4.7(1017 reviews)
520 North 8th Street, Sheboygan, WI
Brick and Mortar Family Owned Collectible Store Based Out of Sheboygan, Wisconsin
Gnome Games Green Bay West
Top Rated4.7(471 reviews)
2160 South Ridge Road, Green Bay, WI
Gnome Games Green Bay West is located just four blocks South of Lambeau Field – home of the Green Bay Packers!
Board Game Barrister
Top Rated4.7(400 reviews)
2500 North Mayfair Road, Wauwatosa, WI
They have a really large selection of board games, kids games, puzzles, etc. I really liked how the sections were organi…
Mox Mania, LLC
Top Rated4.7(364 reviews)
410 D'onofrio Drive, Madison, WI
More Than a Store, It's a Community Sanctuary There are places where you just buy things, and then there’s Mox Mania, w…
Lake Geneva Games LLC
Top Rated4.7(211 reviews)
918 South Wells Street, Lake Geneva, WI
This a REALLY nice and cozy shop with a few game rooms and a really diverse product line covering all of the most popula…
Green Bay City Cards
Top Rated4.7(133 reviews)
508 Military Avenue, Green Bay, WI
Collectors, this is a great place to buy your Pokemon cards. It is Very organized and priced at fair market value. Wonde…
Battle Brothers Miniature Wargaming
Top Rated4.7(133 reviews)
3821 South Howell Avenue, Milwaukee, WI
Battle Brothers Miniature Wargaming is a retail store and social gaming club that focuses on providing our local communi…
Grandma's Toy Box LLC
Top Rated4.7(109 reviews)
223 East Wall Street, Eagle River, WI
Owners Jim & Kathy Holperin are Eagle River natives, and both their families have run businesses on Wall St….the Holperi…
Gamers Realm
Top Rated4.7(104 reviews)
14666 West National Avenue, New Berlin, WI
Tucked away in New Berlin, Wisconsin, this trading card hotspot has earned a stellar 4.7-star rating from over a hundred…
Marblehead's Games
Top Rated4.7(70 reviews)
6300 22nd Avenue, Kenosha, WI
Marblehead's Games is a game, comics, and collectible store in Kenosha, Wisconsin featuring board games, role playing ga…
Ultimate Authentics Sports Cards and Memorabilia
Top Rated4.7(51 reviews)
1621 Westgate Road, Eau Claire, WI
Diamond in the rough! If you blink you'll miss it! At Least I did 😆 This is one of the best card shops in EC! Greal dea…
Coulee Cards & Gaming Wausau
4.7(47 reviews)
2205 Grand Avenue, Wausau, WI
Nestled in the heart of Wisconsin, Wausau is home to a dedicated sports card haven that’s earned a loyal following. With…
Rabbit Hole Sports Cards
4.7(33 reviews)
302 East Towne Way, Madison, WI
Sports Hobby Store, Entertainment Hobby Store, Sports Trading Cards
Eagle Craft & Hobby
4.7(30 reviews)
211 East Wall Street, Eagle River, WI
Owners Jim & Kathy Holperin are Eagle River natives, and both their families have run businesses on Wall St….the Holperi…
Kryptonite Kollectibles
4.6(484 reviews)
1441 Plainfield Avenue, Janesville, WI
Welcome to Kryptonite Kollectibles, your one-stop-shop for card games, RPGs, and board games. Not to mention a great pla…
Colosseum Games
4.6(419 reviews)
5719 75th Street, Kenosha, WI
Shop our inventory of board games, role playing games, Warhammer, and more!
Game Universe
4.6(404 reviews)
6550 South Lovers Lane Road, Franklin, WI
Game Universe is a game store with three locations in the Greater Milwaukee Area. We host regular events just about ever…
Chimera Hobby Shop Fond Du Lac
4.6(370 reviews)
65 West Scott Street, Fond du Lac, WI
Shop Chimera Fond Du Lac to find great deals on all kinds of trading card games, board games, table top games, and more!…
Game Universe - Brookfield
4.6(294 reviews)
19555 West Bluemound Road, Brookfield, WI
Game Universe is a game store with three locations in the Greater Milwaukee Area. We host regular events just about ever…
Wisconsin has 226 trading card shops listed in our directory across 99 cities, with an average rating of 4.6 stars.
Wisconsin's card shops carry a wide range of TCG and sports card products, with the most popular being Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!. You'll find stores specializing in Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports cards, and more.
The cities with the most card shops in Wisconsin are Appleton (14), Eau Claire (12), Madison (12).
Browse our directory by city above, or use the search bar to find card shops in your area. Each listing includes store hours, ratings, directions, and the games they carry.
CardShopDir