Shop
1211 I Avenue, New Castle, IN 47362
Closed10AM–5PM
Tucked away in New Castle, Indiana, this top-rated spot is a haven for sports card collectors. With a stellar 4.9-star rating from 11 reviews, it offers a focused selection of trading cards—primarily sports cards covering baseball, basketball, football, and more. Whether you’re hunting for vintage singles or modern sealed boxes, the inventory is curated for both casual
39.9168138, -85.3711102
Open in Google Maps →
Play at the Plate Cards & Games
200 South Green River Road, Evansville, IN
Play at the Plate Cards & Games is a trading card shop in Evansville, IN, located at 200 South Green River Road. The sto…
Timmys Card Castle
117 East Center Street, Bourbon, IN
Timmys Card Castle is a trading card shop in Bourbon, IN, located at 117 East Center Street. The store carries Pokemon,…
Enterprise Games
330 Westminster Drive, Noblesville, IN
Enterprise Games is a trading card shop in Noblesville, IN, located at 330 Westminster Drive. The store carries a variet…
Experience Point
10015 Archer Drive, Brownsburg, IN
Experience Point is a trading card shop in Brownsburg, IN, located at 10015 Archer Drive. The store carries a variety of…
Casket City Games
312 South Eastern Avenue, Batesville, IN
Casket City Games is a trading card shop in Batesville, IN, located at 312 South Eastern Avenue. The store carries Pokem…
Top Level Trades
Top Rated5.0(157 reviews)
525 Wabash Avenue, Lafayette, IN
Top Level Trades is a trading card shop in Lafayette, IN, located at 525 Wabash Avenue. The store carries a variety of t…
CardShopDir