Shop
3501 North Granville Avenue, Muncie, IN 47303
Open10AM–8PM
Tucked away in Muncie, Indiana, this sports card hotspot has earned a solid 4.6-star rating from 19 local collectors. Squeeze Play specializes in trading cards across all major sports, offering everything from single packs and boxes to singles and supplies for the serious hobbyist. Open six days a week, the shop provides a welcoming space for buyers, sellers, and traders to browse inventory, chat stats, or hunt for that elusive rookie card. Whether you’re chasing baseball, basketball, football, or hockey, the selection aims to keep both casual fans and seasoned veterans engaged. Stop by to check their current stock and join a community that’s clearly passionate about the game—both on the field and in the binder.
Generation Sports Cards and More
5.0(7 reviews)
3501 North Granville Avenue, Muncie, IN
Sports Cards and Memorabilia are bought here at Generation Sports. We have NFL, MLB, NBA, Pokémon, and more!
All Star Sports Cards
4.9(34 reviews)
2170 West White River Boulevard, Muncie, IN
Tucked away in Muncie, this spot has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from 34 reviews for good reason. All Star Sports C…
Three Strikes Sports Cards & Hobby
4.9(17 reviews)
413 South Tillotson Avenue, Muncie, IN
Tucked away in Muncie, Indiana, this gem has become a go‑to for sports card collectors. With a stellar 4.9‑star rating f…
Timmys Card Castle
117 East Center Street, Bourbon, IN
Timmys Card Castle is a trading card shop in Bourbon, IN, located at 117 East Center Street. The store carries Pokemon,…
Experience Point
10015 Archer Drive, Brownsburg, IN
Experience Point is a trading card shop in Brownsburg, IN, located at 10015 Archer Drive. The store carries a variety of…
Play at the Plate Cards & Games
200 South Green River Road, Evansville, IN
Play at the Plate Cards & Games is a trading card shop in Evansville, IN, located at 200 South Green River Road. The sto…
Casket City Games
312 South Eastern Avenue, Batesville, IN
Casket City Games is a trading card shop in Batesville, IN, located at 312 South Eastern Avenue. The store carries Pokem…
Enterprise Games
330 Westminster Drive, Noblesville, IN
Enterprise Games is a trading card shop in Noblesville, IN, located at 330 Westminster Drive. The store carries a variet…
Top Level Trades
Top Rated5.0(157 reviews)
525 Wabash Avenue, Lafayette, IN
Top Level Trades is a trading card shop in Lafayette, IN, located at 525 Wabash Avenue. The store carries a variety of t…
40.2227720, -85.3759160
Open in Google Maps →
CardShopDir