10 shops listed in Indianapolis, Indiana. Find local game stores for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports cards, and more — with hours, ratings, and directions.
Indianapolis, Indiana (IN) is home to 10 trading card shops listed in our directory, ranging from dedicated TCG specialists to comic and game stores that carry a wide range of collectible products. The most popular games among Indianapolis's shops are Pokemon (5 shops), Flesh and Blood (2 shops), Riftbound (2 shops). Use our directory to find local card stores near you in Indianapolis, with hours, ratings, directions, and the games they carry — including Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and sports cards.
Indy Card Exchange
Top Rated4.8(335 reviews)
7035 East 96th Street, Indianapolis, IN
Have a child 13 & Under that is into collecting cards? Consider signing them up for the Indy Card Exchange Kids Club! Ou…
Mage's Comics and Games
Top Rated4.8(140 reviews)
7623 Shelby Street, Indianapolis, IN
One of the biggest, widest selection of comic books I've been to locally. Definitely one of my favorites specifically fo…
Saltire Toys & Games
Top Rated4.7(309 reviews)
11135 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN
We’ve been going to them for years for presents for our young kids as well as others. It truly feels like the games and…
Fan Cave
4.5(112 reviews)
4805 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
The second Midnight Madness of 2025 will be in June! - Trade Night - Refreshments - Special Deals - Grand Prize Giveawa…
Grandmaster Games
4.2(393 reviews)
4200 South East Street, Indianapolis, IN
Super awesome game place with great variety specifically for trading card games or board games. Staff has always been am…
The Game Preserve
Top Rated4.7(392 reviews)
8487 Union Chapel Road, Indianapolis, IN
The mission of The Game Preserve is to delight our customers and attract new ones by operating game stores which offer o…
The Toy Drop
Top Rated4.7(228 reviews)
6025 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
The Toy Drop store is located on the Southside of Indianapolis. The Toy Drop specializes in rare, vintage, and modern to…
Paradigm Games
Top Rated4.7(86 reviews)
2479 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN
Paradigm Games is a trading card shop in Indianapolis, IN, located at 2479 North Meridian Street. The store carries Poke…
Good Games Indianapolis
4.5(455 reviews)
111 South Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN
Been there a few times now. They have an awesome selection of games and they know their MTG cards. It is always clean an…
Game Time
4.3(363 reviews)
8244 Center Run Drive, Indianapolis, IN
8244 Center Run Dr.Indianapolis, IN 46250317-577-0900 Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter Hours: Monday:…
Indianapolis, Indiana has 10 trading card shops listed in our directory.
Indianapolis's card shops carry a range of TCG and sports card products, with the most popular being Pokemon, Flesh and Blood, Riftbound. You'll find stores specializing in Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports cards, and more.
Browse the shop listings above, or use the search bar to find card shops in Indianapolis by name. Each listing includes store hours, ratings, directions, and the games they carry.
CardShopDir